@@ -3365,17 +3365,21 @@ Errata Management</h4>
33653365 be annotated inline
33663366 alongside the affected [=technical report=] text
33673367 or at the start or end of the most relevant section(s).
3368+ Inline errata are treated as <a href="#class-2">class 2 changes</a> ,
3369+ and are published accordingly.
3370+
3371+ An [=erratum=] <em class="rfc2119"> may</em> be accompanied by a
3372+ [=candidate amendment=] proposing a solution to the issue.
33683373
33693374<h4 id=candidate-amendments oldids=candidate-changes>
33703375Candidate Amendments</h4>
33713376
3372- An [=erratum=] <em class="rfc2119"> may</em> be accompanied by a non-normative,
3373- <dfn>candidate correction</dfn> approved by [=group decision=] .
3374- When annotated inline,
3375- errata--
3376- including their [=candidate corrections=] --
3377- must be marked as such,
3378- are treated as <a href="#correction-classes">class 2 changes</a> ,
3377+ A <dfn>candidate amendment</dfn> is a non-normative annotation,
3378+ marked as such,
3379+ integrated into a [=technical report=] by [=group decision=]
3380+ to indicate a potential [=substantive change=]
3381+ that has not yet been formally adopted.
3382+ They are treated as <a href="#class-2">class 2 changes</a> ,
33793383 and are published accordingly.
33803384
33813385 Note: Annotating changes in this way allows more mature documents
@@ -3385,13 +3389,6 @@ Candidate Amendments</h4>
33853389 sufficient review or implementation experience
33863390 to be normatively incorporated into the specification proper.
33873391
3388- A <dfn>candidate addition</dfn> is similar to a [=candidate correction=] ,
3389- except that it proposes a new feature
3390- rather than an error correction.
3391-
3392- [=Candidate corrections=] and [=candidate additions=] are collectively known as
3393- <dfn lt="candidate amendment">candidate amendments</dfn> .
3394-
33953392 In addition to their actual [[#maturity-stages|maturity stage]] ,
33963393 [=published=] [=REC Track=] documents with [=candidate amendments=] are also considered,
33973394 for the purpose of the W3C Patent Policy [[PATENT-POLICY]] ,
@@ -3408,7 +3405,7 @@ Maintenance Without a Group</h4>
34083405 <ol>
34093406 <li> <a href="#class-1">class 1 changes</a> ;
34103407 <li> inline [=errata=] ;
3411- <li> [=candidate corrections=] ,
3408+ <li> [=candidate amendments=] not including <a href="#class-4">class 4 changes</a> ,
34123409 which <em class=rfc2119> must</em> be marked as <dfn>Team correction</dfn> ;
34133410 <li> <a href="#class-2">class 2 changes</a> other than inline [=errata=] and [=Team corrections=] .
34143411 </ol>
@@ -3637,15 +3634,6 @@ Maturity Stages on the Recommendation Track</h4>
36373634 (in accordance with [[#revising-rec]] )
36383635 to address [=editorial change|editorial=] or [=substantive change|substantive=] issues
36393636 that are discovered later.
3640- However, <a href=#class-4>new features</a> can only be added
3641- if the document already identifies itself
3642- as intending to <dfn>allow new features</dfn> .
3643- Adding or removing this allowance is a [=substantive change=] .
3644- Such an allowance cannot be added
3645- to a [=technical report=] previously published as a [=Recommendation=]
3646- that did not allow such changes;
3647- this requires a new [=technical report=]
3648- (which could, for example, be similarly named but with an incremented version number).
36493637
36503638 As technology evolves,
36513639 a [=W3C Recommendation=] may become:
@@ -4163,20 +4151,10 @@ Requirements for Transition</h5>
41634151 <em class="rfc2119"> must</em> identify, in the document, where errata are tracked.
41644152 </ul>
41654153
4166- Additionally,
4167- if the document has previously been published as a [=W3C Recommendation=] , the [=Working Group=]
4168- <em class=rfc2119> must not</em> include any <a href="#correction-classes">class 4 change</a>
4169- to that publication
4170- unless it was explicitly marked as [=allowing new features=] ,
4171- and <em class=rfc2119> must not</em> include any such marking
4172- if not already present.
4173-
41744154 If the document's most recent publication is a [=Candidate Recommendation Draft=] ,
41754155 the [=Team=] <em class=rfc2119> must</em> verify
41764156 that it contains no changes since the previous [=Candidate Recommendation Snapshot=] other than:
41774157 * [=editorial changes=] ,
4178- * the addition or removal of a statement as to whether the document will [=allow new features=]
4179- after its publication as a [=Recommendation=] .
41804158 * dropping [=at risk=] features
41814159
41824160 Otherwise, the [=Working Group=] <em class=rfc2119> must</em> republish it
@@ -4257,18 +4235,19 @@ Revising a Recommendation: Editorial Changes</h5>
42574235 to make this class of change without passing through earlier maturity stages.
42584236 (See <a href="#class-1">class 1</a> and <a href="#class-2">class 2 changes</a> .)
42594237
4260- <h5 id="revised-rec-substantive">
4238+ <h5 id="revised-rec-substantive" oldids="revised-rec-features" >
42614239Revising a Recommendation: Substantive Changes</h5>
42624240
4263- Tentative corrections (see <a href="#class-3">class 3 changes</a> )
4241+ Tentative [=substantive changes=]
4242+ (see <a href="#class-3">class 3</a> and <a href="#class-4">class 4 changes</a> .)
42644243 <em class=rfc2119> may</em> be annotated into a [=Recommendation=]
4265- using [=candidate corrections =] .
4244+ using [=candidate amendments =] .
42664245
4267- Note: [=Candidate corrections =] do not normatively modify the document;
4246+ Note: [=Candidate amendments =] do not normatively modify the document;
42684247 they editorially indicate how one might do so.
42694248 They are therefore published following the provisions of [[#revised-rec-editorial]] .
42704249
4271- A [=candidate correction =] can be made normative
4250+ A [=candidate amendment =] can be made normative
42724251 and be folded into the main text of the [=Recommendation=] ,
42734252 once it has satisfied all the same criteria
42744253 as the rest of the [=Recommendation=] ,
@@ -4285,30 +4264,19 @@ Revising a Recommendation: Substantive Changes</h5>
42854264 or, if the relevant criteria are fulfilled,
42864265 <a href="#transition-cr">publish as a Candidate Recommendation</a> --
42874266 and advance the specification from that state.
4288- (See <a href="#correction-classes">class 3 changes</a> .)
4289-
4290- <h5 id="revised-rec-features">
4291- Revising a Recommendation: New Features</h5>
4292-
4293- For [=Recommendations=] explicitly identified as [=allow new features|allowing new features=] ,
4294- tentative new features (see <a href="#correction-classes">class 4 changes</a> )
4295- <em class=rfc2119> may</em> be added as [=candidate additions=] in annotations,
4296- and <a href="#correction-classes">class 4 changes</a> may be normatively incorporated
4297- in the same fashion as <a href="#correction-classes">class 3 changes</a> in [[#revised-rec-substantive]] .
4298-
4299- Note: Limiting the addition of new features to [=Recommendations=] that explicitly allow them
4300- enables third parties to depend on a stable feature-set for [=Recommendations=] that do not advertise that ability,
4301- as was the case for all [=Recommendations=] prior to the 2020 revision of this Process.
4302-
4303- Note: When a [=Recommendation=] does not [=allow new features=] ,
4304- new features can be added by creating a new [=technical report=]
4305- and following the full process of advancing that [=technical report=] to [=Recommendation=] --
4306- beginning with a new [=First Public Working Draft=] .
4307- Such [=technical reports=] could be written to represent
4308- additional modules building on top of the original [=Recommendation=] of the core technology,
4309- or an expanded replacement of the original [=Recommendation=] of the core technology
4310- (in which case the new [=technical report=] will typically have the same name as the original,
4311- with an incremented version number).
4267+
4268+ <div id=allow-features-note class=note>
4269+ <span class=marker> Note:</span>
4270+ In earlier version of the Process,
4271+ new features (<a href="#class-4">class 4 changes</a> ) could only be added to [=Recommendations=]
4272+ that had explicitly opted into this ability
4273+ prior to their first publication as [=Recommendation=] .
4274+ Otherwise,
4275+ new features could only be added by creating a new [=technical report=]
4276+ and following the full process of advancing that [=technical report=] to [=Recommendation=] --
4277+ beginning with a new [=First Public Working Draft=] .
4278+ For simplicity, this restriction has been lifted.
4279+ </div>
43124280
43134281<h5 id=change-review>
43144282Incorporating Candidate Amendments</h5>
@@ -4321,16 +4289,9 @@ Incorporating Candidate Amendments</h5>
43214289 must be announced to other W3C groups, the public, and the [=Advisory Committee=] .
43224290 The announcement <em class="rfc2119"> must</em> :
43234291 <ul>
4324- <li>
4325- Identify whether this is a
4326- <dfn>Last Call for Review of Proposed Corrections</dfn> ,
4327- <dfn>Last Call for Review of Proposed Additions</dfn> ,
4328- or <dfn>Last Call for Review of Proposed Corrections and Additions</dfn> .
4329-
43304292 <li>
43314293 Identify the specific [=candidate amendments=] under review
4332- as <dfn>proposed amendments</dfn>
4333- (<dfn export>proposed corrections</dfn> /<dfn oldids="proposed-addition" export>proposed additions</dfn> ).
4294+ as <dfn>proposed amendments</dfn> .
43344295
43354296 <li>
43364297 Specify the deadline for review comments,
@@ -4347,10 +4308,6 @@ Incorporating Candidate Amendments</h5>
43474308 Also, the review initiated by the [=Last Call for Review of Proposed Amendments=]
43484309 is an [=Advisory Committee Review=] .
43494310
4350- Note: [=Last Call for Review of Proposed Additions=] and
4351- [=Last Call for Review of Proposed Corrections and Additions=]
4352- can only be issued for [=Recommendations=] that [=allow new features=] .
4353-
43544311 A [=Working Group=] <em class="rfc2119"> may</em> batch
43554312 multiple [=proposed amendments=] into a single <a>Last Call for Review of Proposed Amendments</a> .
43564313 To facilitate review,
@@ -4704,7 +4661,7 @@ Revising W3C Statements</h4>
47044661 an [=Advisory Committee review=] of the changes it wishes to incorporate.
47054662 The specific [=candidate amendments=] under review
47064663 <em class=rfc2119> must</em> be identified as [=proposed amendments=]
4707- just as in a [=Last Call for Review of Proposed Corrections =] .
4664+ just as in a [=Last Call for Review of Proposed Amendments =] .
47084665
47094666 The decision to incorporate [=proposed amendments=] into [=W3C Statement=] is a [=W3C Decision=] .
47104667 [=Advisory Committee representatives=] may initiate an [=Advisory Committee Appeal=] of the decision.
@@ -5471,6 +5428,37 @@ Appendix A: Retired Terminology</h2>
54715428 <dd>
54725429 Last defined <a href="https://www.w3.org/2014/Process-20140801/#def-W3CChair">in section 2.2 of the 2014 Process</a> ,
54735430 now called [=CEO=] .
5431+
5432+ <dt>
5433+ <dfn noexport>Allow new features</dfn>
5434+ (retired term)
5435+ <dd>
5436+ Last defined <a href="https://www.w3.org/policies/process/20250818/#allow-new-features">in section 6.3.1 of the 2025 Process</a> .
5437+ See also <a href="#allow-features-note">the note</a> at the end of [[#revised-rec-substantive]] .
5438+
5439+ <dt>
5440+ <dfn noexport>Candidate correction</dfn> and <dfn noexport>candidate addition</dfn>
5441+ (retired terms)
5442+ <dd>
5443+ Last defined in <a href="https://www.w3.org/policies/process/20250818/#candidate-amendments">section 6.2.5 of the 2025 Process</a> .
5444+ Both were subtypes of [=candidate amendment=] and are no longer formally distinguished.
5445+
5446+ <dt>
5447+ <dfn noexport>Proposed corrections</dfn> and <dfn oldids="proposed-addition" export>proposed additions</dfn>
5448+ (retired terms)
5449+ <dd>
5450+ Last defined in <a href="https://www.w3.org/policies/process/20250818/#change-review">section 6.3.10.4 of the 2025 Process</a> .
5451+ Both were subtypes of [=proposed amendment=] and are no longer formally distinguished.
5452+
5453+ <dt>
5454+ <dfn noexport>Last Call for Review of Proposed Corrections</dfn> ,
5455+ <dfn noexport>Last Call for Review of Proposed Additions</dfn> , and
5456+ <dfn noexport>Last Call for Review of Proposed Corrections and Additions</dfn>
5457+ (retired terms)
5458+ <dd>
5459+ Last defined in <a href="https://www.w3.org/policies/process/20250818/#change-review">section 6.3.10.4 of the 2025 Process</a> .
5460+ All were subtypes of [=Last Call for Review of Proposed Amendments=] ,
5461+ and are no longer formally distinguished.
54745462 </dl>
54755463
54765464<h2 id="acks" class="non-normative nonum">
0 commit comments